- On August 11, 2004 in Nashville, TN, Williams won a 22 Man gauntlet for the gold match to capture the X Division title.
- On August 22, 2004, Williams defeated Jack Evans in a tournament final to claim the TPW Jr. title for the Wrestle Aid promotion in Japan.
- Williams defeated Alex Shelley on October 20, 2004 in Bloomington, IN to retain the TNA X Division title.
- Williams successfully defended the X Division title by defeated AJ Styles at the Victory Road PPV in Orlando, FL.
- On September 19, 2004 in Windsor, Ontario, Williams and Bobby Roode defeated Truth Martini and N8 Mattson to capture the BCW (Border City Wrestling) Tag Team title.
- At the Turning Point PPV in Orlando, Williams defeated Chris Sabin to retain the X Division title.
- Williams was voted the Wrestling Observer rookie of the year for 2004.
- At Destination X, Team Canada defeated America's Most Wanted, BG James and Konnan.
- At the Hard Justice PPV, Williams and Eric Young defeated Apolo and Sonny Siaki.
- At the 2005 Sacrifice PPV, Team Canada defeated America's Most Wanted and The Naturals.
- Williams defeated Chris Sabin and Matt Bentley in an "Ultimate X" match at TNA's Bound for Glory PPV.
- Team Canada (Williams, A-1, Roode, and Young) defeated the 4 Live Kru at the 2005 Turning Point.
- Williams defeated Puma at the 2006 Sacrifice PPV to win the World Cup gauntlet match.